All About Our Family Reunion in Bear Lake

Last weekend we went to Utah for a family reunion at Bear Lake. Here are all the details about our stay, the VRBO we rented, and how we make it work as a family.

This past week we went to Bear Lake for our family reunion with my siblings and parents.

We’ve been doing this reunion since 2012, and used to do it every other summer, but in the last few years we’ve done it every summer.

I grew up going to reunions every other summer on my dad’s side, and every few years with my mom’s side. Our family has spread all over the country over the years, so it’s a great chance to get everyone together and have a fun and memorable weekend.

Here was our schedule for the weekend, and some answers to your questions from Instagram:

Thursday, June 20th 

• Check in at 4:00 p.m.
• Dinner  (Lemon Chicken Alfredo, pre-cooked chicken, ready to assemble at the house) BRADSHAWS
• Family Pictures – JANSSEN AND MERRICK in charge
• Family Come Follow Me devotional – WHITES
  • Put tomorrow’s dinner in the crockpot to begin cooking

Friday, June 21st

• Breakfast – Cereal/breakfast sandwiches – CRAWFORD + BAILEY
• Morning at the clubhouse pool, gym, and pickleball courts
• Lunch at the house – Sandwiches, chips, fruit, veggies – MCBRIDES
• Swim at the clubhouse pool, games in the yard
• Dinner (Cafe Rio burritos and salads) – WHITES
• Family Come Follow Me devotional – BRADSHAWS

Saturday, June 22nd

• Breakfast: Cereal/breakfast sandwiches – CRAWFORD + BAILEY
• Minute to Win It Games – CRAWFORD + BAILEY (details about these later!)
• Lunch at the house – leftover Cafe Rio
• Ice Cream and Raspberry Shakes at Float On
• Beach Day at North Beach
  • Bring Kayaks and beach toys from the house
  • Mom and dad bring rented lilypad
• Dinner – pizza ordered and picked up from Summit Pizza (we bought 5 large pizzas and that was plenty for all of us)
• Family Temple fireside – DAD
• Family movie – Kids in the basement, adults upstairs

Sunday, June 23rd

• Breakfast: Cereal/breakfast sandwiches – CRAWFORD + BAILEY
• Everyone pack sack lunches for the road – MCBRIDES
• Check out at 10am
• Church in Logan at 11:30
• Lunch at a park after church
• Everyone drives home

We kept it super simple and very flexible. We have lots of little kids, so we switched things up as needed and for various activities some people joined and some did not. We just made it work!

Here are answers to your questions about our trip!

Q: Where did you stay in Bear Lake?

We stayed in Fish Haven Idaho this year at this gorgeous VRBO house.

The first time we did a family reunion in Bear Lake, we stayed in a smaller house in Garden City, which was a little closer to downtown with all the restaurants. It felt busier and more crowded, and the house was definitely more squished, with smaller spaces to gather, and families sharing bathrooms. We found this amazing house three years ago, which is about 15 minutes farther up the lake, and we loved it so much that we’ve come back three times!

The house is in a gated community that has access to a clubhouse with two pools, a hot tub, a sports court with pickleball and basketball and tennis courts, and a gym. The owner of the VRBO also put in a basketball and pickleball court on property last year, so that was a super fun addition for the kids.  It was endless fun in the mornings, afternoons, and evenings, in between trips to the lake.

Q: How did you find the house you stayed in? (Friends, Air bnb, VRBO?)

Three years ago, we just searched on Airbnb and VRBO. We had a general budget, and knew roughly how many bedrooms and bathrooms we needed, so that helped us narrow our search. When we had a mediocre experience with the first Bear Lake house we stayed in, we looked for something a little more spacious and found THIS HOUSE. It’s our second time staying there because we have had such a great experience and it has plenty of space and rooms and beds.

The most important thing for us is that every family had their own bedroom and bathroom. Our first year, families had to share a bathroom and it’s just tight and uncomfortable sometimes. This house has 7 bedrooms and 6.5 bathrooms and was perfect for our family of 21.

The adults each got their own rooms, all the girl cousins shared one bunk room, and all the boy cousins (except my sister’s youngest, who is 3) shared the other bunk room.

Q: How far in advance did you begin planning and finding a place?

Things book up very quickly in Bear Lake, so we’ve had this booked since last July. We just choose dates at the reunion and get it booked for the following year so we don’t have to stress about it. If you’re thinking about next summer, it’s a great idea to get it booked now.

Q: How many people did you have?

We had 21 total, 10 adults and 11 kids.

• My parents
• My older sister and her husband and four girls
• My younger sister and her husband and four boys
• My family with our three boys
• My younger brother and his wife

Q: Which company did you rent a boat from?

My sister’s family got a boat a few years ago, so we used their boat last year. This year, we had our reunion earlier than in the past, so the lake was freezing, and the boat trailer had a tail light out, so my sister decided not to bring it. Without the boat, there’s still plenty to do — we did the beach, played at the pool, played sports, and just spent time together as a family. The boat is a bonus, but not necessary.

But in the past few Bear Lake reunions before we had a boat, we’ve rented a boat.

Here are the details:

We rented through Epic Recreation at the RV Park and Marina location, which was about 20 minutes from our house. We rented the 12 Person 23′ Surf Boat and the accessory package for 8 hours.

Our first year at Bear Lake, we rented for 6 hours and it was not enough time for all of us to get the time we needed on the boat (since we had to split into two groups and switch out in the middle).

There was another boat rental place closer to our house called Performance Rental, so we checked out their website on the way home, thinking maybe we’d rent from them the next year. But their prices were higher and their reviews were worse. At Epic, they were super friendly and helpful and we had a great experience.

Some people have asked about how we handled the rental, and if anyone has driving experience. My brother in law grew up boating, so he knew how to drive a rental boat (although every boat is a little different, I think, so they gave him a little tutorial when we picked it up). If you don’t have anyone in your family with boat driving experience, especially driving while people are doing water sports, I’d say that you probably shouldn’t rent a boat. I would personally never feel comfortable doing that when I have zero experience.

Q: Where did you rent the giant mat from?

My sister rented this from SUP Rentals in Springville our first year and it was a favorite among the cousins, so we had to bring it back the last few years. My parents were driving from Las Vegas and my dad has a truck, so they picked it up and hauled it to the lake.

You can also buy them HERE.

Q: What is a good beach area?

Our first year we went to Rendezvous Beach, which was fine. It was very crowded and you have to pay per car to enter.

The second year ago, my brother in law got us access to Ideal Beach, which is a private beach for residents. His parents own a condo there, so he was able to get us in. It was much less crowded, and much nicer, but not accessible for most.

The owner of our rental house recommended North Beach, so we’ve done that the last two years and it’s a great option. It’s $14 per car to enter, and we brought three cars in (one was the truck with the boat), but it was a much bigger beach and nicer sand.

Q: Is the water freezing?

In the past, it’s been chilly, but not freezing. If you’re boating, you get used to it fairly quickly. Last year, it was VERY COLD when we were on the boat, so my sister brought their wetsuits for wake surfing on the boat, and that make the whole experience MUCH more enjoyable.

This year, we went in mid June, so it was the coldest we’d experienced. Definitely too cold to swim. There were almost no boats on the lake this early.

It was much warmer toward the edges of the lake, so when we played at the beach, the kids still got in the water and they were fine.

Q: What activities did you have for kids and adults?

The house had a few toys, a pool table, and an XBox. But the clubhouse gave us most of the activities, with swimming, foosball, pickleball, and basketball.

We also brought some games and the Minute to Win It activities.

Q: Do you have fun family traditions you do at each reunion?

Minute to Win It has been a tradition for the last few years. Usually we do it the first night, as a little “ice breaker,” but this year my parents and brother got in pretty late so we were rushing to take pictures and have dinner and do our family devotional, so we didn’t do it til day 3 in the morning.

We also always take a nice family picture (someone brings a camera and a tripod to use).

Besides that, we haven’t been really consistent about anything in particular. The last two years we’ve been at the lake, so we do a boat day and a beach day.

Q: What Minute to Win It Games do you play? 

Here are the Minute to Win It Games we’ve played this year and in the past:

• Face the Cookie: Place an Oreo or sandwich cookie on your forehead. You have one minute to use your facial muscles to move the cookie down your face and into your mouth—without using your hands!
• Suck it Up: You’ll need straws and two plates per person. Place 20 M&M’s on one plate, and you have one minute to see how many candies they can transfer from one plate to another with the suction from the straw and no hands.
• How’s It Hangin’: With a cut of yarn, tie a banana around your waist so it hangs between your legs and almost touches the ground. Without hands, you have to swing the banana and hit a wiffle ball from point A to point B in one minute.
• Card Ninja: Place a large bowl in the center of a coffee table or on the ground. Everyone gets a deck of playing cards (make sure they have different designs so you can differentiate, and each person throws them (kind of like throwing stars) into the bowl. Whoever gets the most cards into the bowl in one-minute wins.
• Cotton Ball Nose: You’ll need two cereal bowls placed in front of each person. Put a large handful of cotton balls in one bowl. Everyone gets a swipe of vaseline on their nose, and using ONLY their nose, they need to transfer as many cotton balls from one bowl to the other in one minute.
• Rubber Band Bullseye: Place plastic or paper cups on a flat surface. You can do different levels if you’d like — my brother took the bar stools and created a little tower of stacked stools and placed the cups on different levels around the tower. Using thick rubber bands (like from a newspaper), stand a designated distance away and try to shoot down as many cups as possible in one minute.
• Keep Balloons Up: Give everyone two blown up balloons, and they have to keep both of them up in the air as long as they can in one minute.

Q: How did you split up meals and household chores?

We split up meals between families, as you can see in the schedule above. My older sister and I were in charge of one dinner each, my younger sister was in charge of three lunches, my brother was in charge of all breakfasts, and my parents bought pizza one night, and brought snacks for the house.

It’s most cost effective and efficient for one family to be in charge of all the breakfasts, or all the lunches, so several families aren’t each bringing a gallon of milk, or multiple boxes of cereal. Otherwise you end up with way too much food.

We all love cooking and being together, so even though one family is in charge of a meal, everyone pitches in to help prepare, and then everyone cleans up. There were no specific assignments for cleaning.

Q: What is the Cafe Rio pork recipe you used?

My family was in charge of Friday night dinner and this is what I made. It’s always a hit.

I used THIS RECIPE from Heidikins Cooks. I’ve been making this recipe for a decade and it’s amazing. Just make sure you get a good cut of meat — that extra fat on a pork butt shoulder makes it super tender and makes the juice really soak in and make it very flavorful.

We also used THIS RECIPE for the cilantro lime rice, Heidikin’s recipe for the ranch dressing (but we added more mayo and less buttermilk cause otherwise it’s way too runny), and bought uncooked tortillas and mexican pinto and black beans from the grocery store.

I start cooking the meat with just water and salt the night before, and then add the sauce ingredients in the morning. It’s a bit of a labor of love an hour before dinner to head the beans, cook and prepare the rice, cook the tortillas, make the dressing, and get out all the toppings (store bought pico de gallo, cheese, tortilla strips, etc), but everyone pitches in and helps, so it goes fairly quicky.

Q: How do you handle the finances of the reunion?

In the past, we’ve split the cost of the house 5 ways (per family). Before my sister’s family got their boat, my parents covered the cost of renting the boat, and then we split the meals up according to assignment. Each of us purchased our own groceries for our assigned meals before arriving (groceries in Bear Lake are expensive, so it’s important for us to get groceries in Logan before we come up…that saves us quite a bit).

We also all individually paid for our own travel expenses. It was most expensive for us since we had to buy 5 plane tickets, and also more expensive for my brother and his wife since they flew in from NYC.  My sisters live about 3 1/2 hours away from Bear Lake by car, and my parents live in Las Vegas so they drove up (which was about a 9 hour drive for them).

Not everything is exactly even, but that’s real life and everyone is good about paying for their part.

Last year and this year, my parents decided to pay for the house, and then everything else has stayed the same, but up to this point we’ve always split the cost of everything.

Q: What were the sleeping arrangements?

The VRBO house has plenty of room, so all the adults get their own room and bathroom, and there are two bunk rooms. One with 6 beds for all the older boys, and one with 4 beds for all the girls. There are some other open spaces with pull out couches and beds, but so far we don’t have to use those.

Q: Where do you take family photos?

There is LOTS of empty space all around the houses in the gated community, so there are plenty of spots to take family pictures. We just walked through the brush behind the house and found a good spot, but you could find places all over!

We just brought a tripod and remote and took pictures with my sister’s nice camera. We’ve hired a photographer in the past, but the tripod has worked really well so just do it on our own now.

Q: Who plans it? (one person, divide and conquer, etc)

We rotate through each year, with one family officially in charge, but everyone else helps out as needed. Since we’re in the same spot and same house multiple years in a row, it’s been super easy to have the same format and just repeat every year. This year my brother and his wife were in charge.

Q: Do you pick the same date every year?

No, it just depends on everyone’s schedules. In the past, we’ve always done it in July, but this year we had some conflicts, so we decided to do it in June. That made it colder at the lake, but we made it work! Typically, we decide on a date at our current reunion and get the next year booked right away!

Q. Is Bear Lake still fun without a boat?

Yes! I mentioned above that we didn’t have a boat this year, and it was still very fun. BUT the place we stayed has a big sports court and two pools and a hot tub, so there is plenty to do even without a boat. If we didn’t have those amenities, I think it would be a little less fun without a boat. But I mentioned above that you can rent a boat, and I shared the rental details we had in the past!

Q. How do you all agree on time/place?

We decided a few years ago on Bear Lake, and it was so fun that we decided to do it over and over again. So that made it easy. This year, we decided that our time at Bear Lake has been fun, but we’re ready to move on and try other places. We had a family meeting after the kids went to bed and discussed finances and options and scheduling, and we’ve come up with some ideas for future years that are in new locations. My parents are planning to serve an LDS mission next year and will be gone for 18 months, so we plan to do next year’s family reunion wherever they end up being called, and then the next year we’ll do somewhere in new Utah so it’s more affordable for the family members who live there. After that, we’ll alternate between a new destination and a new Utah location.

Raspberry Creami recipe?

Bear Lake is famous for it’s Raspberry Shakes. They’ve been around for decades, and there are lots of places in the area that now serve them. We tried out Float On on the way to North Beach, and although the shake was good, I still felt like the healthier Raspberry Creami recipe was just as good, if not better. So if you want to try it, here’s our recipe:

INGREDIENTS:

• 1 cup Fairlife whole milk, plus a few extra tablespooons
• 1 scoop vanilla protein powder (I like THIS BRAND and code “MERRICKWHITE” works for 10% off)
• Royal Brand sugar free raspberry jell-o
• Fresh or frozen raspberries

Using a frother or whisk, combine the milk and protein powder together in a Ninja Creami container until no clumps remain, and freeze this for at least 8 hours until fully frozen.

Sprinkle half a packet of Royal brand sugar free raspberry jell-o on top and then mix in the Creami on “Light Ice Cream” setting.

Scrape the sides of the container, then add a 2-3 more tablespoons of milk. Set to “Light Ice Cream” and push “Re-mix” on the machine.

Scrape the sides one more time, if needed, then add your frozen or fresh raspberries, and mix on the “Mix In” setting. Serve immediately.

If you have any other questions, feel free to ask!

IF YOU LIKED THIS POST, YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE THESE POSTS!

• All about our family reunion trip to Hawaii

• Our favorite places in Southern California

• Universal Studios: Things to know before you go